Headed to ACS San Diego? Join us for Happy Hour!
← Back to glossary

Ligand Efficiency (LE)

Method
Method
Method

For a given series, Ligand Efficiency (LE) can be used as a metric in drug discovery to evaluate the binding energy of a ligand relative to its size. It’s typically expressed as the binding free energy per non-hydrogen atom. Increasing molecular size increases affinity through increased interactions, however, it may also I) reduce solubility, II) lead to non-specific binding, III) increase clearance. Beyond a certain point, an increase in size also has diminished returns due to higher desolvation costs. As such, it is recommended that an increase in size should be associated with an increase in binding affinity appropriate for the binding pocket.

Importance in Computational Drug Discovery:

  • Enables fair comparison of binding affinities across molecules of varying sizes within a given series, avoiding bias toward larger ligands.
  • Guides fragment-based drug discovery by identifying small, efficient binders as starting points for optimization.
  • Supports lead optimization by balancing potency with molecular size, reducing the risk of poor pharmacokinetics.
  • Facilitates virtual screening and ranking of hits by integrating efficiency metrics into scoring functions.
  • Avoids unnecessary molecular complexity during hit-to-lead and lead optimization phases.

Key Tools

  • MOE (Molecular Operating Environment): Calculates ligand efficiency and related metrics during molecular modeling and screening.
  • Schrödinger Suite (Glide, Maestro): Provides ligand efficiency scoring as part of docking and lead optimization workflows.
  • SeeSAR: Visualizes and optimizes ligand efficiency directly in the context of protein-ligand complexes.
  • DataWarrior: Analyzes and plots ligand efficiency metrics across compound libraries.
  • KNIME Analytics Platform: Enables custom calculation and visualization of ligand efficiency in data workflows.
  • Deep Origin Tools: Balto supports ligand efficiency optimization by providing tools to calculate binding affinity per heavy atom, enabling the prioritization of potent and efficient lead compounds in drug discovery.

Literature

"The role of ligand efficiency metrics in drug discovery"

  • Publication Date: 2014-01-31
  • DOI: 10.1038/nrd4163
  • Summary: This comprehensive review discusses the application of ligand efficiency (LE) metrics in drug discovery. It emphasizes how LE metrics, including lipophilic ligand efficiency (LipE), can guide the optimization of fragments, hits, and leads by balancing binding affinity with molecular properties such as size and lipophilicity. The paper also explores the role of LE in assessing target druggability and improving the quality of drug candidates.

"The nature of ligand efficiency"

  • Publication Date: 2019-01-31
  • DOI: 10.1186/s13321-019-0330-2
  • Summary: This article critically examines the concept of ligand efficiency, highlighting its dependence on the concentration units used to express affinity. It argues that while LE is a useful concept, the metric itself may lack physical meaning due to its sensitivity to arbitrary unit choices. The paper suggests alternative approaches for assessing binding efficiency that are less dependent on such variables.

"Molecular Complexity and Its Impact on the Probability of Finding Leads for Drug Discovery"

  • Publication Date: 2001-04-27
  • DOI: 10.1021/ci000403i
  • Summary: This study explores the relationship between molecular complexity and the likelihood of identifying viable lead compounds in drug discovery. It emphasizes the importance of considering ligand efficiency within structurally related series, as comparisons across unrelated series may be misleading due to differences in molecular complexity.

"Ligand efficiency as a guide in fragment hit selection and optimization"

  • Publication Date: 2010-11-01
  • DOI: 10.1016/j.ddtec.2010.11.003
  • Summary: This article explores the use of ligand efficiency scores in fragment-based drug discovery. It reviews how LE metrics can guide the selection and optimization of fragment hits, emphasizing their role in identifying promising starting points for lead development.

"Validity of Ligand Efficiency Metrics"

  • Publication Date: 2014-07-10
  • DOI: 10.1021/ml500146d
  • Summary: This paper investigates the theoretical underpinnings of ligand efficiency metrics, examining their validity and limitations. It discusses how LE metrics relate to thermodynamic principles and evaluates their usefulness in comparing compounds across different chemical series.